patching...
Update: Want your youth sports league results on Melrose Patch? Have opinions on the 2012 elections? Blog on Melrose Patch! »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

State to School Committee: Announce Release of Meeting Minutes

An Open Meeting Law complaint had been filed last summer against the Melrose School Committee regarding the announcement and notification to the public of the release of the committee's executive session minutes.

 

The state Attorney General's Office reminded the Melrose School Committee last summer that when executive session minutes are released, the committee must announce their availability, according to a letter released this week by the state.

The letter closes an Open Meeting Law complaint filed with the Attorney General Office's Division of Open Government by resident Maryan Hollis, a regular attendee of School Committee meetings.

Hollis filed the complaint in followup to another complaint she had filed that resulted in the state ordering the committee to release and announce the release of executive session minutes from two meetings held in the fall of 2010.

The committee released those minutes shortly after the Attorney General's order, according to a letter from Assistant Attorney General Jonathan Sclarsic dated Jan. 10, 2012 (PDF attached), but did not announce the minutes' release at an open meeting, as required by state law.

The Attorney General's Office then discussed that requirement with Mary Jo Hollender, the committee's counsel, around June 22 and the committee made a public announcement regarding the release of the minutes during its July 12 meeting. The committee has made similar announcements at meetings since then.

This week's letter states that the Attorney General's Office now considers the matter closed and is "satisfied that the Committee has now complied with our May 4, 2011 order.

"Where, as occurred here, a public body takes corrective action in response to a complaint filed with that body, we strongly encourage complainants to reconsider whether further review by this office remains necessary," the letter said. "As a final matter, we remind the Committee and other public bodies of the importance of announcing the release of any executive session minutes during an open session meeting. Without such an announcement, the public has no means of knowing that such records are available."

Melrose Patch contacted last year's committee Chairwoman Margaret Driscoll and current Chairwoman Kristin Thorp for comment; they emailed a joint statement.

"The Melrose School Committee works very hard to honor the letter and spirit of Open Meeting Law," Thorp and Driscoll's statement read. "This matter is now considered closed by the Attorney General's office. Among our many responsibilities and initiatives, we are focusing our efforts on finding the best possible superintendent candidate to continue improving the educational experience to which Melrose students are entitled."

Related Topics: Melrose School Committee and Open Meeting Law

Steve Meuse

9:16 pm on Friday, January 13, 2012

On a related note, the city doesn't seem to follow the "accessibility" rules for PDFs. PDFs of minutes, bulletins, etc. need to be searchable not just scans of printouts.

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Daniel DeMaina

9:25 pm on Friday, January 13, 2012

Can you point out that rule in the state statute, Steve? I wasn't aware of that and can't seem to find it in the law (http://www.mass.gov/ago/government-resources/open-meeting-law/open-meeting-law-mgl-c-30a-18-25.html). The city currently posts PDF copies of meeting notices online (along with postings inside City Hall and on a monitor viewable 24/7 in a City Hall window: http://patch.com/A-chtv) to adhere to the rule that "except in cases of emergency, a public body must provide the public with notice of its meeting 48 hours in advance, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and legal holidays."

Comment_arrow

Steve Meuse

5:48 pm on Saturday, January 14, 2012

It wouldn't be part of the open meeting law, but would apply as it is a document put out by a government. I never read it myself and couldn't find it with a quick search, but when I was working on some projects for the state, we were told that the law was to always create accessible pdfs when posting them online.

In general though, why would you print it out and then scan it in when you could just print right to a pdf?

Leave a comment